aaron kelly eliminated from american idolEverybody thought Casey James was going home on Idol, right? Well, he didn´t, he was even a top 3 in the votes, since Lee Dewyze was the first one saved by Ryan Seacrest.

Then, came the moment of truth… Crystal “Mamasox” Bowersox and Casey James in one side, Big Mike and Aaron Kelly on the other side… The bottom being this pair.

Aaaand Aaron Kelly is eliminated from American Idol at top 5. What do you think? Are you sad Aaron Kelly is out from American Idol? Who would you rather had gone? Casey? Lee? Mike? Crystal?

Who do you think is going to win it all?

My guess is LeeDewyze wins American Idol Season 9. Head to the comments to let me know your opinion.